I guess i'll use ground coffee or pure cacao powder and a natural oil (coconut), instead. I'll try coffee first, as it is easier to obtain.
I must mention this:
Aloe vera gel (that I know) is gel directly from the leaf and not from a bottle. Many people have access to aloe (we grow aloe, actually) from the leaf. We use the pure aloe gel on skin and hair and even boil it to drink as a tonic (it's a cultural thing and it tastes awful). I've never heard of it being used on eyes, nor do I think anyone should buy the ones sold in stores with additives.